Correction and editor’s note : The original article treated enrollment at low-proficiency schools as a count of children who failed assessments or could not read. That inference was not supported, and the headline and article text have been corrected. Public assessment results are available through state and city education websites. We also corrected the claim of a blanket ban on new charter-school openings and qualified the categorical statement dismissing evidence for smaller classes. Our editorial concerns about proficiency, spending, and accountability remain.
The article text and summary below have been amended. Corrections and Clarifications
America’s public schools used to be the one institution every parent could count on. You sent your kid to school, and the school taught your kid to read. That was the deal. It wasn’t complicated. But in city after city — wherever progressive leaders have held uninterrupted power for decades — that basic compact has collapsed. Not quietly, either. Spectacularly.
The playbook never changes. More spending. More administrators. More initiatives with glossy names and zero results. And when the test scores come back ugly? Too often, in our view, officials soften the language and congratulate themselves on “another incredible year.” The results themselves are publicly available, and deserve more attention. The latest numbers from the nation’s largest school district suggest this strategy has produced something genuinely historic — just not the kind of history anyone should celebrate.
From The Post Millennial:
Nearly 900 New York City public schools are failing to adequately educate students, according to a new report that accuses education officials of allowing poor academic performance to become “normalized” through grade inflation, weak accountability and rising spending.
The report, released by the charter school network Success Academy and titled By Any Honest Measure, found that 906 public schools had fewer than half of their students proficient in math, reading or both on New York state exams last year. According to the analysis, roughly 43% of the city’s approximately 912,000 public school students attend those schools.
The report’s enrollment estimate concerns students attending schools with low proficiency rates; it is not a count of children who individually failed a test or cannot read. At 503 schools, the report found that fewer than half of tested students were proficient in each of the two subjects. That does not establish that the same individual students failed both. Those school-level results are troubling enough without overstating what they show.
A $40 billion reward for failure
New York City spent $40 billion on public education in 2024. That works out to roughly $36,000 per student. Read that figure again. Double the national average. And here’s the kicker: spending surged 67 percent over the previous decade, climbing from $24 billion to $40 billion, even as enrollment dropped by nearly 100,000 students. More money. Fewer kids. Worse outcomes.
The incentive structure is almost comically backwards. The deeper a school fails, the more categorical funding it unlocks. The worst-performing schools frequently receive the highest per-pupil spending. In what other sector of American life does catastrophic incompetence get rewarded with a bigger budget?
Accountability requires clear information
The spending is concerning. The way officials explain academic performance deserves scrutiny too.
In 2015, New York’s state legislature struck the term “failing school” from official regulations. Too harsh, apparently. They replaced it with “struggling school” — because euphemisms fix everything. The report criticizes how officials communicate results and the accessibility of some data files. However, school assessment results are also publicly available through New York State and New York City education websites. Our earlier suggestion that the results were buried exclusively in a proprietary database was incorrect. We believe officials should make those public results easier for families to find and interpret.
Consider this: 98 percent of New York City teachers are rated “effective” or “highly effective.” Meanwhile, 43 percent of students attend schools where most kids can’t pass basic assessments. These measures describe different things and can both be true; their coexistence is not proof that one is fabricated. In our view, the gap still raises legitimate questions about what teacher ratings measure and how schools should be held accountable.
At one failing school, a parent survey skipped the obvious question — are our children learning? — and instead asked whether race and ethnicity were “positively represented in the curriculum.” Ninety-four percent said yes. A positive curriculum survey does not answer the separate question of academic proficiency.
On June 22, socialist Mayor Zohran Mamdani and his schools chancellor released a cheerful video congratulating students on “another incredible year.” Incredible is one word for it.
Decades of progressive leadership built this mess
None of this materialized overnight. According to the report, a third of the 906 failing schools have been cycling through state accountability designations for over a decade — “receiving additional funds and support, merging, rebranding, relabeling, but never turned around.” This is the accumulated wreckage of generations of progressive governance in New York City.
Now it falls to Mamdani to address it. Don’t hold your breath. His administration faces a costly class-size reduction mandate. Research has found benefits from smaller classes in some settings, including early grades, so our categorical dismissal of the evidence was too broad. Whether those findings justify this particular mandate’s costs and implementation is a separate policy question. New York State law also limits charter authorizations, including in New York City, but that is not a blanket city ban on openings: previously approved schools may still open. We favor greater school choice and scrutiny of how restrictions affect families.
The Success Academy report closes with a line worth tattooing on the door of every school administrator’s office in New York: “What is missing is not money. What is missing is honesty.”
Hundreds of thousands of students attend schools with low proficiency rates according to the report. That is a serious school-level concern, not a finding that every child in those schools cannot read. Families should not have to wait another decade for meaningful improvement.
Key Takeaways
- NYC spends double the national average per student while nearly half attend failing schools.
- The report criticizes official language and accountability; state and city assessment results are publicly available online.
- Decades of progressive leadership produced 906 failing schools — and a socialist mayor is unlikely to reverse course.
- State law limits charter authorizations, but previously approved schools may open. Smaller-class research shows benefits in some settings.
Sources: The Post Millennial, Free Beacon
Additional sources: NYC Public Schools: public test results; NYSED assessment data; NYSED charter authorization process; NYSED charter fact sheet; Tennessee STAR class-size study report.